Muscogee Nation sues Henryetta over McGirt jurisdiction violations

July 11, 2025

The Muscogee Nation filed a lawsuit Tuesday against the City of Henryetta and its attorney, John Insabella, for prosecuting Native citizens within reservation boundaries in violation of McGirt v. Oklahoma, according to KOSU. The tribe initially contacted Insabella in September 2024 after learning of the prosecutions but received no response. The tribe later discovered the city's police chief had instructed officers not to involve Muscogee Lighthorse Police in traffic stops involving tribal citizens. Insabella later stated the city would continue prosecuting tribal members.

The lawsuit, filed in the Eastern District court, seeks a declaration that Henryetta lacks criminal jurisdiction over Native defendants. The filing comes amid similar disputes, including a recent Tulsa settlement and a January lawsuit against two district attorneys.

1.KOSU.

1.KOSU.

We provide the independent reporting that non-Native, extractive outlets often overlook. We give our communities the context and the facts they need to make informed decisions.

Jodi Rave Spotted Bear

Founder and Editor in Chief

As a 501(c)(3) nonprofit, we exist to illuminate tribal government decision-making for everyone who cares about transparency about Native issues. Because the consequences of restricted press freedom affect our communities every day, our trauma-informed reporting is rooted in a deep, firsthand expertise. Every gift helps keep the fire burning. A monthly contribution makes the biggest impact.